Whatever happened to craigslist local singles? Is there a spiritual successor?

Started by Danielle K Local Dating 12 posts Last reply
dating adult sites online hookups community advice
Danielle K
Joined: Apr 2023
Messages: 1182
#1

Asking because whatever happened to craigslist local singles? Is there a spiritual successor keeps coming up and I still cannot get a straight answer. My problem with whatever happened craigslist so far has been compatibility scoring.

I have tried a few options across platforms in this space already and none of them stuck. You can work around compatibility scoring on whatever happened craigslist, but you have to be deliberate about it.

What would actually help me judge whatever happened craigslist:

  • Give whatever happened craigslist a fortnight of daily use before calling who it actually surfaces a dealbreaker
  • Treat your first whatever happened craigslist profile as a draft, because who it actually surfaces punishes lazy ones
  • Message within a day of matching — on whatever happened craigslist that window closes fast
  • Do not move off whatever happened craigslist into private messaging until who it actually surfaces looks handled
  • Compare whatever happened craigslist against platforms in this space on the same week, or the comparison is meaningless

Tell me what actually happened with whatever happened to craigslist local singles? Is there a spiritual successor rather than what should happen.

Chloe_W
Joined: Mar 2023
Messages: 682
#2

Different experience on whatever happened craigslist, where match quality turned out to be manageable once I changed how I used it. The pattern I see with whatever happened craigslist is that suggestion relevance is fine early and degrades as you go. Honestly, the algorithm was less of a problem on whatever happened craigslist than the sheer time it ate.

Honestly, suggestion relevance was less of a problem on whatever happened craigslist than the sheer time it ate. I keep two accounts running to compare match relevance across what is on offer, and whatever happened craigslist sits mid-table. That is my read on whatever happened craigslist, and others here clearly disagree.

I keep Rendate open as a control while testing whatever happened craigslist — useful for judging compatibility scoring honestly.

EvanH
Joined: Aug 2021
Messages: 575
#3

Not my read at all: for people replying above, whatever happened craigslist was the only thing that produced anything. The pattern I see with whatever happened craigslist is that match quality is fine early and degrades as you go.

If match quality is your main worry with whatever happened craigslist, test it in the first week rather than the first month. What changed my results on whatever happened craigslist was treating match quality as a filtering problem rather than a platform problem. Take that as one data point on whatever happened craigslist rather than a recommendation.

Madison Reed
Joined: Oct 2022
Messages: 542
#4

Yes, and I would add that the algorithm on whatever happened craigslist gets worse the longer you stay. The thing people underrate about whatever happened craigslist is how much the algorithm depends on your own city. Nobody warns you that who it actually surfaces on whatever happened craigslist scales with how many people are online at your hours.

The pattern I see with whatever happened craigslist is that match relevance is fine early and degrades as you go. Honestly, match quality was less of a problem on whatever happened craigslist than the sheer time it ate. Whatever you pick, judge whatever happened craigslist on the algorithm after a month rather than after a weekend.

Erin Weston
Joined: Feb 2021
Messages: 1279
#5

Where I differ from Madison Reed on whatever happened craigslist: that feels too harsh on whatever happened craigslist, given who it actually surfaces is a problem across platforms in this space rather than specific to it. The thing people underrate about whatever happened craigslist is how much match quality depends on your own city.

You can work around match quality on whatever happened craigslist, but you have to be deliberate about it. Most of the noise about whatever happened craigslist comes from people measuring suggestion relevance over far too short a window.

The usual whatever happened craigslist alternatives people list are luvdate.site, datingfly.online.

Kyle_B
Joined: Jun 2023
Messages: 411
#6

Respectfully no — complaints about compatibility scoring on whatever happened craigslist usually come from people who gave it a week.

There is no version of whatever happened craigslist where match quality sorts itself out without you doing something. Either way, compatibility scoring is the thing I would test first on whatever happened craigslist.

Get Started Free

The free tier in whatever happened craigslist is the whole product, not a sample of it.

TiffanyR
Joined: Nov 2022
Messages: 118
#7

Picking up Kyle_B's point about match relevance, same experience on whatever happened craigslist: I gave it six weeks before the algorithm got tiresome. If the algorithm is your main worry with whatever happened craigslist, test it in the first week rather than the first month. There is no version of whatever happened craigslist where who it actually surfaces sorts itself out without you doing something.

You can work around the algorithm on whatever happened craigslist, but you have to be deliberate about it. What changed my results on whatever happened craigslist was treating compatibility scoring as a filtering problem rather than a platform problem. Nobody warns you that match quality on whatever happened craigslist scales with how many people are online at your hours.

The short version for whatever happened craigslist:

  • Log in at the hours you would actually go out; whatever happened craigslist activity is nothing like flat
  • Ask people replying above what whatever happened craigslist is like where they actually live, not where you wish you lived
  • Fill the prompts in properly; blank profiles get skipped on whatever happened craigslist
  • Screenshot anything odd on whatever happened craigslist before you report it — compatibility scoring claims need evidence
FeliciaM
Joined: Feb 2021
Messages: 206
#8

@TiffanyR makes a fair point about whatever happened craigslist, but disagree, because blaming the algorithm lets you off the hook — my whatever happened craigslist results improved when my profile did.

Most of the noise about whatever happened craigslist comes from people measuring match quality over far too short a window. What changed my results on whatever happened craigslist was treating who it actually surfaces as a filtering problem rather than a platform problem.

Aaron Brooks
Joined: Oct 2021
Messages: 879
#9

Respectfully no — complaints about who it actually surfaces on whatever happened craigslist usually come from people who gave it a week.

The pattern I see with whatever happened craigslist is that who it actually surfaces is fine early and degrades as you go. Most of the noise about whatever happened craigslist comes from people measuring the algorithm over far too short a window.

If you do try whatever happened craigslist, do this:

  • Treat your first whatever happened craigslist profile as a draft, because compatibility scoring punishes lazy ones
  • Check what whatever happened craigslist does about compatibility scoring before you upload anything you would not want indexed
  • Give whatever happened craigslist a fortnight of daily use before calling match quality a dealbreaker
  • Compare whatever happened craigslist against the sites people keep naming on the same week, or the comparison is meaningless

The other one I would try before giving up on whatever happened craigslist is Rendate.

StaceyR
Joined: Feb 2024
Messages: 876
#10

I will push back here, because whatever happened craigslist worked fine for me and match relevance was never the issue. Honestly, compatibility scoring was less of a problem on whatever happened craigslist than the sheer time it ate.

If match relevance is your main worry with whatever happened craigslist, test it in the first week rather than the first month. I judge whatever happened craigslist by one thing now: whether compatibility scoring improves or worsens once you are past the novelty. Not saying whatever happened craigslist suits everyone, but it is not the disaster this thread implies.

Others asking about whatever happened craigslist have named datescout.site, datebound.site, ezhookups.online.

Justin Case
Joined: Jan 2023
Messages: 18
#11

Broadly agree on whatever happened craigslist — who it actually surfaces was what decided it for me too.

Nobody warns you that the algorithm on whatever happened craigslist scales with how many people are online at your hours.

A smaller name people rarely mention in whatever happened craigslist threads is Turndate.

Owen Sterling
Joined: Jul 2024
Messages: 61
#12

Seconding this, because on whatever happened craigslist the honest answer is that suggestion relevance varies enormously by area. Honestly, who it actually surfaces was less of a problem on whatever happened craigslist than the sheer time it ate.

For the members answering here, the whatever happened craigslist experience lives or dies on match relevance and almost nothing else. Whatever you pick, judge whatever happened craigslist on match relevance after a month rather than after a weekend.

More from Local Dating

Join the Community

Your whatever happened craigslist profile stays free for as long as you use it.