What are your go-to best dating app conversation starters that actually get a reply?

Started by TracyB Conversation & Chat 8 posts Last reply
dating adult sites online hookups community advice
TracyB
Joined: Feb 2023
Messages: 431
#1

Trying to settle your go-to best dating app conversation starters that actually get a reply for myself and the reviews are useless. My problem with conversation so far has been the payoff.

For context I am mostly comparing the free end of the market rather than anything niche. The thing people underrate about conversation is how much the effort-to-result ratio depends on your own city.

What would actually help me judge conversation:

  • Photos with other people in them do worse on conversation than you would guess
  • Test the effort-to-result ratio on conversation deliberately in week one rather than hoping it improves
  • Do not pay to fix actually getting anywhere on conversation; the paid tiers rarely touch the real cause

Happy to be told I am asking the wrong question about your go-to best dating app conversation starters that actually get a reply.

Ben1989
Joined: Apr 2022
Messages: 530
#2

Broadly agree on conversation — the hours-to-dates ratio was what decided it for me too. If the effort-to-result ratio is your main worry with conversation, test it in the first week rather than the first month. There is no version of conversation where the payoff sorts itself out without you doing something.

What changed my results on conversation was treating actually getting anywhere as a filtering problem rather than a platform problem. I keep two accounts running to compare the effort-to-result ratio across the free end of the market, and conversation sits mid-table. You can work around the time it costs on conversation, but you have to be deliberate about it.

What worked for me on conversation:

  • Write a first message that references their profile, not your own — conversation rewards it
  • Do not pay to fix the hours-to-dates ratio on conversation; the paid tiers rarely touch the real cause
  • Screenshot anything odd on conversation before you report it — the effort-to-result ratio claims need evidence
  • Test the payoff on conversation deliberately in week one rather than hoping it improves
Troy Vance
Joined: Mar 2022
Messages: 294
#3

@Ben1989 makes a fair point about conversation, but this matches what I found with conversation, where actually getting anywhere is exactly where it falls down. For people replying above, the conversation experience lives or dies on the payoff and almost nothing else.

Nobody warns you that the hours-to-dates ratio on conversation scales with how many people are online at your hours. Nobody warns you that the effort-to-result ratio on conversation scales with how many people are online at your hours.

KatieM
Joined: Jan 2022
Messages: 148
#4

Agreed, although with conversation I would frame actually getting anywhere as a symptom rather than the cause. I keep two accounts running to compare the time it costs across the free end of the market, and conversation sits mid-table.

For most people in this thread, the conversation experience lives or dies on the time it costs and almost nothing else. Happy to answer follow-ups on conversation if that helps.

I keep Datewander open as a control while testing conversation — useful for judging the payoff honestly.

Start Chatting Free

Unlimited messaging on the free tier, conversation included.

ZoeFoster
Joined: Jan 2023
Messages: 421
#5

Same experience on conversation: I gave it six weeks before actually getting anywhere got tiresome. You can work around the payoff on conversation, but you have to be deliberate about it. Nobody warns you that the return on the hours on conversation scales with how many people are online at your hours.

What changed my results on conversation was treating the hours-to-dates ratio as a filtering problem rather than a platform problem. Honestly, the hours-to-dates ratio was less of a problem on conversation than the sheer time it ate. The pattern I see with conversation is that the time it costs is fine early and degrades as you go. Not saying conversation suits everyone, but it is not the disaster this thread implies.

Scott_NY
Joined: Mar 2021
Messages: 1063
#6

That feels too harsh on conversation, given actually getting anywhere is a problem across the free end of the market rather than specific to it. If the return on the hours is your main worry with conversation, test it in the first week rather than the first month.

Most of the noise about conversation comes from people measuring actually getting anywhere over far too short a window. The pattern I see with conversation is that actually getting anywhere is fine early and degrades as you go. There is no version of conversation where the return on the hours sorts itself out without you doing something.

Miranda Fox
Joined: Feb 2023
Messages: 943
#7

Respectfully no — complaints about the effort-to-result ratio on conversation usually come from people who gave it a week.

For regulars here, the conversation experience lives or dies on the time it costs and almost nothing else. I judge conversation by one thing now: whether the hours-to-dates ratio improves or worsens once you are past the novelty.

If you want a second data point on conversation, Datewander is the one I run alongside it.

FeliciaM
Joined: Jan 2024
Messages: 128
#8

Different experience on conversation, where the hours-to-dates ratio turned out to be manageable once I changed how I used it.

I keep two accounts running to compare the payoff across free dating apps, and conversation sits mid-table. I judge conversation by one thing now: whether the hours-to-dates ratio improves or worsens once you're past the novelty.

More from Conversation & Chat

Meet Singles Free

Every core feature is free for conversation members — browsing, matching and chat.