What is a good first message on dating app matches to get a reply?

Started by NathanW Conversation & Chat 12 posts Last reply
dating adult sites online hookups community advice
NathanW
Joined: Oct 2024
Messages: 1291
#1

Genuine question about a good first message on dating app matches to get a reply — I do not have a strong view yet and I want one. The bit nobody covers on first message for matches is compatibility scoring.

For context I am mostly comparing mainstream platforms rather than anything niche. Most of the noise about first message for matches comes from people measuring compatibility scoring over far too short a window.

If you have used first message for matches, these are the bits I care about:

  • Compare first message for matches against mainstream platforms on the same week, or the comparison is meaningless
  • Run first message for matches beside one other option so you have a baseline for the algorithm
  • Do not move off first message for matches into private messaging until the algorithm looks handled

Any first-hand experience with a good first message on dating app matches to get a reply is welcome, good or bad.

Ben1989
Joined: Aug 2024
Messages: 291
#2

That feels too harsh on first message for matches, given who it actually surfaces is a problem across mainstream platforms rather than specific to it. For most of us posting here, the first message for matches experience lives or dies on match relevance and almost nothing else.

What changed my results on first message for matches was treating the algorithm as a filtering problem rather than a platform problem. If match quality is your main worry with first message for matches, test it in the first week rather than the first month. For people who have actually tried it, the first message for matches experience lives or dies on compatibility scoring and almost nothing else.

How I would approach first message for matches from scratch:

  • Test match relevance on first message for matches deliberately in week one rather than hoping it improves
  • Fill the prompts in properly; blank profiles get skipped on first message for matches
  • Photos with other people in them do worse on first message for matches than you would guess
  • Ask most of us posting here what first message for matches is like where they actually live, not where you wish you lived

A smaller name people rarely mention in first message for matches threads is Flurrydate.

Brooklyn92
Joined: Apr 2022
Messages: 1099
#3

@Ben1989 makes a fair point about first message for matches, but disagree, because blaming suggestion relevance lets you off the hook — my first message for matches results improved when my profile did.

Most of the noise about first message for matches comes from people measuring the algorithm over far too short a window. Most of the noise about first message for matches comes from people measuring match quality over far too short a window.

RebeccaT
Joined: Jan 2022
Messages: 1214
#4

Yes, and I would add that match quality on first message for matches gets worse the longer you stay. Honestly, the algorithm was less of a problem on first message for matches than the sheer time it ate.

If who it actually surfaces is your main worry with first message for matches, test it in the first week rather than the first month. Nobody warns you that who it actually surfaces on first message for matches scales with how many people are online at your hours.

A smaller name people rarely mention in first message for matches threads is Datebound.

Patrick Reyes
Joined: Oct 2023
Messages: 357
#5

Agreed, although with first message for matches I would frame suggestion relevance as a symptom rather than the cause. The thing people underrate about first message for matches is how much match quality depends on your own city.

Most of the noise about first message for matches comes from people measuring who it actually surfaces over far too short a window. What changed my results on first message for matches was treating who it actually surfaces as a filtering problem rather than a platform problem. That is my read on first message for matches, and others here clearly disagree.

Kyle_B
Joined: Apr 2022
Messages: 179
#6

Building on what Patrick Reyes said about first message for matches, respectfully no — complaints about who it actually surfaces on first message for matches usually come from people who gave it a week. I keep two accounts running to compare compatibility scoring across the household-name apps, and first message for matches sits mid-table.

There is no version of first message for matches where suggestion relevance sorts itself out without you doing something. Take that as one data point on first message for matches rather than a recommendation.

Anyone comparing first message for matches on the algorithm should probably add Souldate to the list.

Join the Community

Set up a first message for matches profile in under two minutes.

Dave_SoCal
Joined: Nov 2021
Messages: 929
#7

That feels too harsh on first message for matches, given match quality is a problem across the apps everyone has heard of rather than specific to it. The pattern I see with first message for matches is that the algorithm is fine early and degrades as you go.

You can work around suggestion relevance on first message for matches, but you have to be deliberate about it. Not saying first message for matches suits everyone, but it is not the disaster this thread implies.

Madison Reed
Joined: Jan 2023
Messages: 742
#8

Where I differ from Dave_SoCal on first message for matches: same experience on first message for matches: I gave it six weeks before the algorithm got tiresome.

You can work around the algorithm on first message for matches, but you have to be deliberate about it. You can work around match quality on first message for matches, but you have to be deliberate about it.

Erin Weston
Joined: Mar 2025
Messages: 192
#9

Picking up Madison Reed's point about the algorithm, i would argue the opposite on first message for matches: match relevance is the one thing it handles better than the household-name apps.

I keep two accounts running to compare who it actually surfaces across the big apps, and first message for matches sits mid-table. You can work around compatibility scoring on first message for matches, but you have to be deliberate about it.

EvanH
Joined: Mar 2025
Messages: 1108
#10

Disagree, because blaming match relevance lets you off the hook — my first message for matches results improved when my profile did.

Nobody warns you that match relevance on first message for matches scales with how many people are online at your hours. If compatibility scoring is your main worry with first message for matches, test it in the first week rather than the first month.

Jared Stone
Joined: Apr 2023
Messages: 623
#11

That feels too harsh on first message for matches, given match relevance is a problem across the apps everyone has heard of rather than specific to it. Honestly, compatibility scoring was less of a problem on first message for matches than the sheer time it ate.

Most of the noise about first message for matches comes from people measuring match relevance over far too short a window. There is no version of first message for matches where match quality sorts itself out without you doing something. What changed my results on first message for matches was treating compatibility scoring as a filtering problem rather than a platform problem.

AlexaM
Joined: Jan 2022
Messages: 437
#12

That has not been my experience of first message for matches, and I've used it longer than most people in this thread.

I keep two accounts running to compare the algorithm across the big apps, and first message for matches sits mid-table. Nobody warns you that match quality on first message for matches scales with how many people are online at your hours.

I have seen datenest.site, luvdate.site recommended for first message for matches, though I have not tested them properly.

More from Conversation & Chat

Start Free Messaging

No credit card is required at any point for first message for matches members.